All Boards >> Irritable Bowel Syndrome Research Library

HeatherAdministrator

Reged: 12/09/02
Posts: 7687
Loc: Seattle, WA
Older drugs are better than new ones
06/13/13 02:00 PM

New drugs trail many old ones in effectiveness against disease


By Sharon Begley

NEW YORK | Mon Jun 3, 2013 4:04pm EDT

(Reuters) - Despite the more than $50 billion that U.S. pharmaceutical companies have spent every year since the mid-2000s to discover new medications, drugmakers have barely improved on old standbys developed decades ago.

Research published on Monday showed that the effectiveness of new drugs, as measured by comparing the response of patients on those treatments to those taking a placebo, has plummeted since the 1970s.

While that is already unwelcome news to drug and biotech companies, the consequences for the pharmaceutical industry could get worse under President Barack Obama's healthcare law.

The law established an independent research institute to compare the effectiveness of different treatments for the same condition. That way, patients as well as private insurers and government programs such as Medicare can stop paying for less effective therapies. If the new analysis is correct, then "comparative effectiveness research" could conclude that older drugs, which are more likely to be generics, are better than pricey new brand names that deliver the most profits for drugmakers.

Fears of a crisis in drug innovation have grown over the years. When the healthcare journal Prescrire in 2011 ranked new drugs, only 17 of the 984 developed since 2001 were deemed "a real advance" or better. And a survey of 184 expert physicians in 15 specialties published last month in Nature Reviews Drug Discovery showed the doctors were more likely to rate drugs more than a decade old as "transformative."

To be sure, drugs that completely change outcomes for patients continue to emerge. Gleevec, from Novartis, greatly extends life for leukemia patients, for instance. New antivirals such as Incivek from Vertex Pharmaceuticals have doubled the cure rate in hepatitis C, and Eylea from Regeneron Pharmaceuticals is better than anything previously developed for macular degeneration.

Because of those and other examples, "we believe that a lot continues to be accomplished in terms of yielding very, very positive results for patients, so there seems to be a disconnect between that and this paper," said Randy Burkholder, deputy vice president of policy at the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA) trade group.

CANCER TO MENTAL ILLNESS

The new study in the journal Health Affairs examined 315 clinical trials that compared a drug to a placebo and were published in four of the world's top medical journals (BMJ, Journal of the American Medical Association, Lancet and New England Journal of Medicine) from 1966 to 2010. The drugs targeted the full range of human ills, from cardiovascular disease and infections to cancer, mental disorders and respiratory illness.

In the early years, drugs easily beat the placebo: They were, on average, 4.5 times as effective, where effectiveness means how well they lowered blood pressure, vanquished tumors, lifted depression or did whatever else they were intended to.

But the trend line was inexorably downhill, found Dr Mark Olfson of Columbia University and statistician Steven Marcus of the University of Pennsylvania. By the 1980s drugs were less than four times better; by the 1990s, twice as good, and by the 2000s just 36 percent better than a placebo. Since older drugs were much superior to placebo and newer ones only slightly so, that means older drugs were generally more effective than newer ones.

"Their results are pretty compelling," said Dr Aaron Kesselheim of Harvard Medical School, who helped conduct the survey of physicians on "transformative" drugs but was not involved in this study. "It does appear that things are headed in the same direction, with newer drugs having relatively less efficacy."

Experts disagree on why that should be, but suspicions range from the U.S. regulatory process to basic biology.

"It may be that the drug discoveries based on low-hanging fruit were made long ago," said Olfson, as with discoveries based on the most basic or easily targeted causes of high blood pressure. In that case, older drugs based on those targets would pack a bigger punch than newer ones that target less-central causes of disease.

Or, it could be that the patients who volunteer for clinical trials have gotten harder to treat. In many cases, people volunteer because existing drugs are not helping their cancer, schizophrenia or other condition, Olfson said, "and may have forms of the disease where it's harder for a drug to demonstrate a benefit."

Another explanation could be that the scientific quality of clinical trials has improved over the decades, as the Health Affairs analysis found. Human studies in the 2000s were more likely than those in the 1960s to enroll hundreds of patients rather than dozens.

"It may be that the compounds aren't getting less effective but that they're getting looked at more carefully," said Dr Harold Sox of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice and former editor of the Annals of Internal Medicine.

'SOMETHING REAL IS GOING ON'

While experts agree that tougher trials and similar factors explain some of the decline in drugs' reported effectiveness, "something real is going on here," said Olfson. "Physicians keep saying that many of the new things just aren't working as well," and therefore prescribe antidepressant drugs called tricyclics (developed in the 1950s) instead of SSRIs (from the 1980s), or diuretics (invented in the 1920s) for high blood pressure instead of newer anti-hypertensives.

Whatever the reason for many new drugs packing less punch than old ones, that will not keep them from reaching patients.

"The way the drug regulatory system is set up, even if you have just a small advance, if you market it right it can be very profitable," said Kesselheim.

Critics of the high prices of drugs that are only marginally (if at all) more effective than older, cheaper, often generic medications hope that head-to-head studies will persuade more physicians to stop prescribing expensive but less effective drugs. The Affordable Care Act of 2010 - "Obamacare" - established the Patient Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI) to conduct such comparative effectiveness research.

The drug industry says it isn't worried. "Our sector is not concerned about objective, high-quality patient-centered comparative effectiveness research," said PhRMA's Burkholder. "We believe the substantial value of our products will continue to be demonstrated."

(Reporting by Sharon Begley; Editing by Michele Gershberg and Douglas Royalty)

http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/03/us-drugs-effectiveness-idUSBRE95213D20130603

--------------------
Heather is the Administrator of the IBS Message Boards. Shes the author of Eating for IBS and The First Year: IBS, and the CEO of Heather's Tummy Care. Join her IBS Newsletter. Meet Heather on Facebook!

Post Extras Print Post Remind Me! Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Pharmaceutical HeatherAdministrator 07/14/03 01:50 PM
. * Long-term cannabis use increases risk for IBS HeatherAdministrator 10/19/17 04:04 PM
. * FDA approves new drug for chronic constipation HeatherAdministrator 01/26/17 03:05 PM
. * Mixed Opioid Agent Adds to Growing List of Therapies for IBS-D HeatherAdministrator 01/27/16 02:48 PM
. * Low-dose naltreoxone for the treatment of irritable bowel syndrome HeatherAdministrator 01/26/16 01:20 PM
. * Amitiza benefited patients with chronic idiopathic constipation HeatherAdministrator 02/10/15 04:15 PM
. * Medical Marijuana for Digestive Disorders: High Time to Prescribe? HeatherAdministrator 09/17/14 02:08 PM
. * Antibiotics Early in Life May Boost Obesity Risk HeatherAdministrator 08/18/14 03:13 PM
. * Antidepressants, psychological therapies effectively treated IBS HeatherAdministrator 07/15/14 02:49 PM
. * Proton pump inhibitor (acid reflux drugs) may cause heart disease HeatherAdministrator 09/23/13 03:22 PM
. * Older drugs are better than new ones HeatherAdministrator 06/13/13 02:00 PM
. * On Anti-Depressants? Some Raise Risk of C. Diff Infection HeatherAdministrator 05/13/13 05:51 PM
. * Heartburn drugs, NSAID painkillers use linked to IBS symptoms HeatherAdministrator 03/18/13 01:24 PM
. * FDA approves Linzess to treat certain cases of irritable bowel syndrome and constipation HeatherAdministrator 08/31/12 11:25 AM
. * 3-month FDA delay for potential IBS drug linaclotide HeatherAdministrator 04/23/12 01:45 PM
. * Latest FDA watch list includes GI drugs HeatherAdministrator 04/23/12 01:42 PM
. * Antibiotics that reduce gut bacteria linked to obesity HeatherAdministrator 05/06/11 12:25 PM
. * Rifaximin: a unique gastrointestinal-selective antibiotic for enteric diseases HeatherAdministrator 02/10/11 10:23 AM
. * Antacids increase risk of pneumonia HeatherAdministrator 01/14/11 04:35 PM
. * Editorial - Antibiotic Rifaximin (Xifaxan) Therapy for the Irritable Bowel Syndrome HeatherAdministrator 01/07/11 03:01 PM
. * Antiobiotic Rifaximin (Xifaxan) for Patients with Irritable Bowel Syndrome without Constipation HeatherAdministrator 01/07/11 02:59 PM
. * Proton Pump Inhibitor Drugs Tied to 80% Increase in Clostridium difficile Risk HeatherAdministrator 11/10/10 11:29 AM
. * Phase 3 clinical trials of linaclotide for IBS constipation HeatherAdministrator 10/13/10 02:44 PM
. * An over-the-counter drug for constipation offers superior symptom relief compared with a commonly used prescription agent HeatherAdministrator 07/16/10 03:17 PM
. * Benefit/risk ratio of Renzapride not sufficient to warrant further study in IBS-C HeatherAdministrator 04/07/10 01:32 PM
. * Adverse effects of drugs on small intestine and colon HeatherAdministrator 03/16/10 11:23 AM
. * Children's Belly Aches Don't Disappear With Antidepressant HeatherAdministrator 03/11/10 01:14 PM
. * Survey: Marijuana Use In Patients With IBS HeatherAdministrator 01/12/10 03:17 PM
. * FDA Approves Amitiza for IBS-C HeatherAdministrator 05/23/08 10:59 AM
. * Zelnorm no longer available except for emergency use HeatherAdministrator 04/11/08 12:05 PM
. * Clinical trial: phase 2 trial of lubiprostone for irritable bowel syndrome with constipation. HeatherAdministrator 02/15/08 11:20 AM
. * Role of Antibiotics vs Conventional Pharmacotherapy in Treating Symptoms of Irritable Bowel Syndrome HeatherAdministrator 01/03/08 04:45 PM
. * FDA permits the restricted use of Zelnorm HeatherAdministrator 08/09/07 11:41 AM
. * Antidepressant Therapy (Imipramine and Citalopram) for Irritable Bowel Syndrome HeatherAdministrator 06/20/07 01:56 PM
. * Neuromuscular Dysfunction and IBS: Clinical Implications for Drug Use HeatherAdministrator 02/04/07 04:30 PM
. * Enteric Bacteria and IBS HeatherAdministrator 11/26/06 02:51 PM
. * Rifaximin vs Placebo in Reducing Symptoms in Adults With IBS HeatherAdministrator 11/26/06 02:39 PM
. * Antibiotic Rifaximin Appears Safe and Effective for Irritable Bowel Syndrome HeatherAdministrator 10/26/06 10:29 AM
. * Citalopram (Celexa) Improves Symptoms of Irritable Bowel Syndrome HeatherAdministrator 10/14/06 12:57 PM
. * Marijuana eases chronic pain HeatherAdministrator 07/17/06 11:49 AM
. * Doctors group launches war on drug ads HeatherAdministrator 07/17/06 11:17 AM
. * New IBS drug in development in Japan HeatherAdministrator 07/05/06 05:13 PM
. * Marijuana and the gastrointestinal tract HeatherAdministrator 06/12/06 03:38 PM
. * Zelnorm Rejected Again in Europe HeatherAdministrator 04/02/06 03:25 PM
. * Antidepressants for IBS HeatherAdministrator 03/16/06 12:31 PM
. * Takeda Laxative Wins U.S. Approval for Adults HeatherAdministrator 02/18/06 01:36 PM
. * Cilansetron: ; Solvay Pharmaceuticals suspends registration activites in the U.S., HeatherAdministrator 01/18/06 04:15 PM
. * Hearburn Drugs Cause Diarrhea HeatherAdministrator 01/08/06 05:10 PM
. * Zelnorm fails to win EU panel backing HeatherAdministrator 12/21/05 11:25 AM
. * Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and gastrointestinal damage HeatherAdministrator 12/08/05 12:51 PM
. * Octreotide May Be Effective in Treatment of Nonconstipated IBS HeatherAdministrator 12/08/05 12:31 PM
. * Lack of Lasting Effectiveness of Miralax Laxative Treatment of Constipation. HeatherAdministrator 08/07/05 04:18 PM
. * Acute Hepatitis Associated With Lotronex HeatherAdministrator 07/24/05 02:37 PM
. * FDA revisions to safety labeling for Lotronex (alosetron ) HeatherAdministrator 05/22/05 06:46 PM
. * Clinical pharmacology of new motility promoting agents HeatherAdministrator 05/22/05 06:33 PM
. * Rationale for Using Serotonergic Agents to Treat Irritable Bowel Syndrome HeatherAdministrator 05/08/05 06:21 PM
. * Zelnorm Associated With Rare Cases of Severe Diarrhea, Ischemic Colitis HeatherAdministrator 04/24/05 03:48 PM
. * Clinical Response to Tricyclic Antidepressants in Functional Bowel Disorders not Related to Dosage HeatherAdministrator 03/28/05 01:32 PM
. * Efficacy and Safety of Alosetron in Men with Diarrhea-Predominant IBS HeatherAdministrator 02/19/05 05:56 PM
. * Irritable Bowel Syndrome Medications Side Effects Survey HeatherAdministrator 11/09/04 02:04 PM
. * On the Relationship Between Colon Ischemia, Irritable Bowel Syndrome, and Serotonergic Therapy of Irritable Bowel Syndrome HeatherAdministrator 10/24/04 07:10 PM
. * New Risk Information on Zelnorm for IBS for Women HeatherAdministrator 07/11/04 02:18 PM
. * The Relationship among Previous Antimicrobial Use and H. Pylori Infections HeatherAdministrator 06/27/04 01:33 PM
. * Therapeutic benefits of cannabis in migraine, fibromyalgia, irritable bowel syndrome HeatherAdministrator 06/04/04 03:54 PM
. * Pharmaceutical companies funding a number of studies into IBS in the UK HeatherAdministrator 05/25/04 12:00 PM
. * Irritable bowel syndrome helped by Paroxetine, a drug for depression HeatherAdministrator 05/10/04 02:15 PM
. * Fears cause low sales of Lotronex HeatherAdministrator 05/10/04 01:46 PM
. * Zelnorm Warning Issued by FDA HeatherAdministrator 05/10/04 01:01 PM
. * Renzapride Improves Symptoms in Constipation-Predominant Irritable Bowel Syndrome HeatherAdministrator 12/01/03 06:14 PM
. * Clinical Trial Guidelines for Pharmacological Treatment of IBS - Pharmacological Options HeatherAdministrator 12/01/03 05:55 PM
. * SOLVAY presses ahead with cilansetron, a new IBS drug HeatherAdministrator 11/18/03 03:43 PM
. * Measuring Treatment Effects in IBS Trials HeatherAdministrator 10/20/03 03:30 PM
. * FDA Orders Novartis To Pull Zelnorm Ads HeatherAdministrator 10/07/03 11:25 PM
. * Step-down dosage of PPI drugs for hearburn HeatherAdministrator 09/30/03 01:26 PM
. * Evaluation of drug treatment in irritable bowel syndrome HeatherAdministrator 09/30/03 12:52 PM
. * Pain Relievers and Intestinal Disorders HeatherAdministrator 09/16/03 04:20 PM
. * Hypersensitivity and hyperreactivity in IBS: opportunity for drug discovery HeatherAdministrator 07/18/03 12:39 PM
. * Antidepressants in the Treatment of IBS and Other Functional GI Disorders HeatherAdministrator 07/18/03 12:20 PM
. * Use of Antidepressants in the Treatment of IBS? HeatherAdministrator 07/14/03 03:58 PM
. * Combined use of SSRIs and NSAIDs increases the risk of GI adverse effects HeatherAdministrator 07/14/03 03:15 PM

Extra information
0 registered and 11 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Heather 



Permissions
You cannot post until you login
You cannot reply until you login
HTML is enabled
UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 348884

Jump to

| Privacy statement Help for IBS Home

*
UBB.threads™ 6.2


Shop For IBS Here!