All Boards >> Eating for IBS Diet Board

View all threads Posts     Flat     Threaded

The Dimona, Israel, diet study
      07/19/08 03:53 PM
Sand

Reged: 12/13/04
Posts: 4490
Loc: West Orange, NJ (IBS-D)

Quote:

Another weight loss study was published this week. This one, partly funded by Atkins Research Foundation, pitted a low-fat diet against a Mediterranean diet against an Atkins-like diet. The news has either declared Atkins the winner, or that they all worked, or that they all failed.



Quote:

At the end of the two year mark, the overall weight losses among the 322 participants, respectively, were:

[Low-fat] −2.9 kg [±4.2] —7.3 pounds

[Moderate fat Mediterranean] −4.4 kg [±6.0] —10.1 pounds

[Low carbohydrate Atkins like] −4.7 kg [±6.5] —12.1 pounds

In other words, they lost one to 1.5 ounces a week by dieting for 2 years, with a difference of less than 4[sic - should be 5] pounds between the various diets after 2 years. Clinically, this is insignificant. But that's not the full story.




The Junkfood Science article I'm quoting goes on to explain procedural problems with the study including the great classic of all weight loss programs - misreporting on people who drop out. It also provides a link to the New England Journal of Medicine article that reports the results so you can do your own analysis.

Frankly, I found the Junkfood Science article discouraging - she points out the similar lack of success in other studies - but I have to admit this makes a lot of sense (emphasis mine):

Quote:

Since the first low-calorie diet book was published nearly a century ago, diet doctors have come up with every imaginable gimmick for reducing calories, manipulating macronutrients in every conceivable way. If anything was truly effective, after nearly a century, there would be no diet industry and everyone would be slim.




--------------------
[Research tells us fourteen out of any ten individuals likes chocolate. - Sandra Boynton]

Print     Remind Me     Notify Moderator    

Entire thread
* Help! Not handling carbs well!
Fen
07/18/08 06:12 PM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
LeslieS
07/24/08 08:03 AM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
kim123
07/24/08 02:13 PM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
GaGa
07/24/08 08:47 AM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
redwriter1
07/26/08 03:17 PM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
Zara
07/26/08 11:16 PM
* Re: What is the SCD Diet????
fancymom
07/27/08 05:12 AM
* Re: What is the SCD Diet????
Zara
07/27/08 07:16 AM
* Re: What is the SCD Diet????
Zara
07/27/08 07:23 AM
* Re: What is the SCD Diet????
Fen
07/27/08 05:23 AM
* Re: What is the SCD Diet????
Jordy
07/27/08 01:43 PM
* Re: What is the SCD Diet????
Zara
07/27/08 01:54 PM
* Whoops
Jordy
07/27/08 02:04 PM
* Re: Whoops
Fen
07/27/08 04:40 PM
* wait....
Jordy
07/29/08 01:37 PM
* Re: wait....
Fen
07/29/08 02:46 PM
* Thanks for the tip on align!
Jordy
07/28/08 08:11 AM
* Re: Thanks for the tip on align!
giveluv2all
07/29/08 03:21 PM
* Re: Thanks for the tip on align!
Fen
07/28/08 08:46 AM
* Re: Thanks for the tip on align!
dragonfly
07/29/08 05:46 PM
* Re: Thanks for the tip on align!
Fen
07/29/08 05:51 PM
* Which...
Jordy
07/30/08 10:16 AM
* Re: Which...
Fen
07/30/08 10:20 AM
* P.S.
Fen
07/30/08 10:21 AM
* Re: Thanks for the tip on align!
Zara
07/28/08 08:59 AM
* Re: Thanks for the tip on align!
Fen
07/28/08 02:01 PM
* Re: Thanks for the tip on align!
Zara
07/28/08 10:12 PM
* Re: What is the SCD Diet????
fancymom
07/27/08 05:40 AM
* Re: What is the SCD Diet????
Jordy
07/27/08 01:46 PM
* Re: What is the SCD Diet????
Fen
07/27/08 06:07 AM
* Re: What is the SCD Diet????
GaGa
07/27/08 08:14 AM
* Re: Ladies,listen up!
dragonfly
07/27/08 09:21 AM
* adaptation
Little Minnie
07/20/08 07:58 PM
* Re: adaptation
Zara
07/21/08 08:37 AM
* Re: adaptation
fancymom
07/21/08 10:06 AM
* Re: adaptation
Zara
07/21/08 10:52 AM
* Re: adaptation
fancymom
07/21/08 12:03 PM
* totally!
Little Minnie
07/21/08 05:20 PM
* Re: totally!
Zara
07/21/08 10:08 PM
* Re: totally!
fancymom
07/22/08 10:07 AM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
kim123
07/18/08 07:44 PM
* The Dimona, Israel, diet study
Sand
07/19/08 03:53 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
kim123
07/19/08 05:06 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
Sand
07/20/08 03:18 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
fancymom
07/20/08 04:59 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
kim123
07/20/08 03:50 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
fancymom
07/20/08 05:01 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
GaGa
07/20/08 03:29 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
fancymom
07/20/08 05:08 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
fancymom
07/19/08 06:44 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
kim123
07/19/08 09:05 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
kim123
07/27/08 02:36 PM
* Kim
Jordy
07/27/08 02:07 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
GaGa
07/20/08 04:39 AM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
Zara
07/19/08 10:35 PM
* Spelt
Jordy
07/22/08 06:32 AM
* Re: Spelt
Zara
07/22/08 10:21 AM
* Re: Spelt
Jordy
07/23/08 09:23 AM
* Re: Spelt
Zara
07/23/08 09:11 PM
* Re: Spelt
Jordy
07/24/08 06:20 AM
* Re: Spelt
Zara
07/22/08 11:11 PM
* Re: Spelt
Jordy
07/23/08 09:21 AM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
kim123
07/20/08 07:22 AM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
GaGa
07/20/08 08:12 AM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
fancymom
07/20/08 02:47 PM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
kim123
07/20/08 08:21 AM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
GaGa
07/20/08 10:25 AM
* Re: The Dimona, Israel, diet study
fancymom
07/19/08 04:34 PM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
Fen
07/19/08 04:01 AM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
kim123
07/19/08 06:42 AM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
fancymom
07/19/08 06:53 AM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
Draupadi
07/19/08 08:19 AM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
GaGa
07/19/08 01:22 PM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
fancymom
07/19/08 04:36 PM
* Re: Help! Not handling carbs well!
sharond
07/19/08 02:26 PM

Extra information
0 registered and 2568 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Heather 



Permissions
      You cannot post until you login
      You cannot reply until you login
      HTML is enabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 57660

Jump to

| Privacy statement Help for IBS Home

*
UBB.threads™ 6.2


HelpForIBS.com BBB Business Review