All Boards >> Eating for IBS Diet Board

View all threads Posts     Flat     Threaded

Gosh Jen ....
      11/12/06 05:43 PM
Syl

Reged: 03/13/05
Posts: 5499
Loc: SK, CANADA

... you have made a strong criticism.
Quote:

I just don't find using Google to find different Internet articles to be "the science of IBS". It's misleading to try and represent something absolutely when you've only got iffy studies with small sample sizes.




Google is a rather crude tool. I only use it to do preliminary research overviews. I do my primary research using much more powerful tools. I use many subscription-only on-line research databases including the ISI Web of Knowledge.. It covers research published in 15,000 plus of the topic scientific journals for the past 75+ years. I use these databases to research articles. I do keyword searches to locate potentially interesting articles and then read the abstracts. Once I locate an interesting article I use on-line journal subscriptions to retrieve the original article to archive and read.

Most of the articles I read are not available via Google .

Many of the abstracts of the articles are available on Google because abstracts are used to advertise articles.

I maintain a large digital library of original articles on IBS, bowel dysfunction and related illnesses. In fact just this afternoon I added about 15 new articles. Three articles gave compeling evidence for the use of probiotics to treat IBS. In fact in one article they described how a probiotic of Escherichia coli made such an improvement in the lining of the small bowel that it could be seen using a new technology called a Pill Cam. Three other articles discussed the gender distribution subtypes of IBS in Korea, China and Japan screened using ROME I & II and compared the findings to the rest of World. The total sample sizes in these articles were greater than 10,000 individuals. One reason I like to use review articles is that reviewers examine results from many studies effectively increasing the sample size.

Most interestingly I came across article that gives detailed dietary guidelines to manage fructose malabsorption and symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome. I have not studied it in detail yet but I will. A quick scan seems to show it has many similarities to the EFI diet. I will report back when I know more. Here is the abstract
Quote:

Dietary fructose induces abdominal symptoms in patients with fructose malabsorption, but there are no published guidelines on its dietary management. The objective was to retrospectively evaluate a potentially successful diet therapy in patients with irritable bowel syndrome and fructose malabsorption. Tables detailing the content of fructose and fructans in foods were constructed. A dietary strategy comprising avoidance of foods containing substantial free fructose and short-chain fructans, limitation of the total dietary fructose load, encouragement of foods in which glucose was balanced with fructose, and co-ingestion of free glucose to balance excess free fructose was devised. Sixty-two consecutively referred patients with irritable bowel syndrome and fructose malabsorption on breath hydrogen testing underwent dietary instruction. Dietary adherence and effect on abdominal symptoms were evaluated via telephone interview 2 to 40 months (median 14 months) later. Response to the diet was defined as improvement of all symptoms by at least 5 points on a -10- to 10-point scale. Forty-eight patients (77%) adhered to the diet always or frequently. Forty-six (74%) of all patients responded positively in all abdominal symptoms. Positive response overall was significantly better in those adherent than nonadherent (85% vs 36%; PP<0.01 for all symptoms). This comprehensive fructose malabsorption dietary therapy achieves a high level of sustained adherence and good symptomatic response.



Reference
Shepherd SJ, Gibson PR (2006). Fructose malasborption and symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome: guidelines for effective dietary management . Journal of the American Dietetic Association 106 (10): 1631–9.

--------------------
STABLE: ♂, IBS-D 50+ years - Science of IBS

The FODMAP Approach to Managing IBS Symptoms
Evidence-based Dietary Management of Functional GI Symptoms: The FODMAP Approach
FODMAP Chart & Cheatsheet
The Role of Food & Dietary Intervention in IBS

Print     Remind Me     Notify Moderator    

Entire thread
* High Fructose Corn Syrup-D?
Naturapanic
11/06/06 09:02 PM
* Post for Jeio
Sand
11/14/06 05:38 PM
* Post for MCV
Sand
11/14/06 05:36 PM
* Re: Post for MCV
MCV
11/15/06 06:00 AM
* Post for Syl
Sand
11/14/06 05:32 PM
* Apples are high in fructose
Syl
11/07/06 05:31 AM
* Re: Apples are high in fructose
germanicus1991
11/13/06 08:15 PM
* Re: Apples are high in fructose
Syl
11/14/06 07:13 AM
* Re: Apples are high in fructose
germanicus1991
11/13/06 08:37 PM
* apples
Jordy
11/07/06 06:30 AM
* Re: apples
Karen18
11/07/06 09:39 AM
* Re: appleswith NO SKIN
Joannelcoq
11/15/06 11:25 AM
* It seems everyone is different
Jordy
11/15/06 12:22 PM
* Re: apples
Jordy
11/07/06 12:04 PM
* Re: apples
Lisa Marie
11/07/06 02:56 PM
* Re: apples
Syl
11/07/06 03:28 PM
* Re: apples
Lisa Marie
11/09/06 08:28 AM
* Re: apples
K2
11/07/06 04:06 PM
* Oranges hard for lots of people?-nt
Jordy
11/09/06 12:25 PM
* Re: apples
Naturapanic
11/07/06 07:32 PM
* Who knows!
Jordy
11/09/06 05:59 PM
* Avoid HFCS as much as possible. Eat the apple. -nt-
Sand
11/08/06 08:07 AM
* Humbly disagree
Syl
11/08/06 08:20 AM
* Re: Humbly disagree
Gracie
11/08/06 08:32 PM
* Re: Humbly disagree
Sand
11/08/06 08:56 AM
* Re: Humbly disagree
Syl
11/08/06 09:01 AM
* Re: Humbly disagree
Jordy
11/08/06 12:49 PM
* Re: Humbly disagree
Syl
11/08/06 01:10 PM
* Re: Humbly disagree
Sand
11/09/06 01:58 PM
* Further thoughts....
Syl
11/09/06 03:30 PM
* Re: Further thoughts....
Sand
11/11/06 04:00 PM
* Sorry you took it that way ...
Syl
11/11/06 04:50 PM
* IBS and science
jen1013
11/12/06 03:47 PM
* Gosh Jen ....
Syl
11/12/06 05:43 PM
* Re: Gosh Jen ....
jen1013
11/14/06 01:09 PM
* Re: Gosh Jen ....
Sand
11/14/06 09:13 AM
* More information ....
Syl
11/14/06 09:40 AM
* Only 1 in 3?
Sand
11/14/06 10:08 AM
* Re: More information ....
K2
11/14/06 09:45 AM
* Your are correct ....
Syl
11/14/06 09:50 AM
* Funny...
Sand
11/14/06 10:09 AM
* Try one of these definitions
Syl
11/14/06 10:38 AM
* Re: Try one of these definitions
MCV
11/14/06 10:41 AM
* Re: Try one of these definitions
Jeio
11/14/06 12:46 PM
* Re: Your are correct ....
K2
11/14/06 10:00 AM
* Re: Your are correct ....
Syl
11/14/06 10:28 AM
* Re: Your are correct ....
MCV
11/14/06 10:39 AM
* I agree ...
Syl
11/14/06 02:29 PM
* Re: I agree ...
GaiasSong
11/14/06 05:11 PM
* I agree with MCV...
Double J
11/14/06 01:52 PM
* What does Heather say about fructose?
Jordy
11/14/06 06:04 PM
* I think that fructose is a trigger for some folks...
HeatherAdministrator
11/15/06 11:01 AM
* Thank you!
Jordy
11/15/06 12:02 PM
* Trying to understand
Jordy
11/14/06 08:40 AM
* Re: Trying to understand
K2
11/14/06 08:46 AM
* Re: Trying to understand
Jordy
11/14/06 10:16 AM
* Re: Trying to understand
K2
11/14/06 10:23 AM
* Thanks for trying to help me, Kat
Jordy
11/14/06 06:02 PM
* Re: Thanks for trying to help me, Kat
K2
11/14/06 07:56 PM
* Re: Thanks for trying to help me, Kat
Jordy
11/15/06 07:12 AM
* right on
Syl
11/14/06 09:03 AM
* Re: I agree
K2
11/12/06 03:52 PM
* Sand ...
Double J
11/11/06 04:08 PM
* Re: Sand ...
Syl
11/11/06 04:47 PM
* It's not readily availble
Jordy
11/08/06 01:34 PM
* Re: Humbly disagree
Sand
11/08/06 09:23 AM
* Sand just love your posts always make me smile nt
susieannah
11/08/06 02:37 PM
* Re: Humbly disagree
MCV
11/08/06 09:31 AM
* PS
Jordy
11/07/06 01:17 PM
* Re: Apples are high in fructose
Naturapanic
11/07/06 06:16 AM
* Re: High Fructose Corn Syrup-D?
franny
11/07/06 04:43 AM
* You can eat natural applesauce, though?
Jordy
11/07/06 06:31 AM
* Re: You can eat natural applesauce, though?
Jeio
11/07/06 03:55 PM

Extra information
0 registered and 2509 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Heather 



Permissions
      You cannot post until you login
      You cannot reply until you login
      HTML is enabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 65328

Jump to

| Privacy statement Help for IBS Home

*
UBB.threads™ 6.2


HelpForIBS.com BBB Business Review