I like the paper to come from the top BUT its because of the doo-hicky we have on our dispenser. In Japan, everyone has a doo-hicky attached (hanging from the dispenser) to have an extra roll ready if you run out. The doo-hicky is made of fabric and if you put the roll in so that it comes from the bottom - it snags and you spend most of your time swatting the roll trying to get the smallest piece! So I HAVE to put the roll so it comes from the top. This doo-hicky is soooooo convenient! No more embarassing moments stranded in the bathroom! I'm taking a bunch home with me when I move back to give as presents!