My surgeon didn't even blink about taking it out. I met with him and he said "whats your med history" to which I replied " A LONG history of belly pain..." and we discussed it all. He said he can't promise to take all of my symptoms, but could help some. I gave it a shot and it worked. No one even warned me about NOT taking it out... so I was confused to hear about you! I guess everyone is different, and honestly--they aren't sure how bad i have IBS, if at all... so I'm in a different boat I guess. And yes, the $$ I'm saving is well worth it! By the way, I'm eating white bread--whole grain is tough on normal people's belly, so I'm sticking with white for awhile... I'm so happy to eat all of this again-- I'm still being healthy, but the thought of going out to eat is so exciting. I am feeling like my life is back... so for me, it was well worth it. I am so glad no doc ever questioned it for me! Hang in there...it's bound to be figured out!