All Boards >> Eating for IBS Diet Board

View all threads Posts     Flat     Threaded

Re: Here's something I'm curious about
      06/27/05 04:59 PM
jen1013

Reged: 05/06/05
Posts: 1322
Loc: the wabe

Quote:

Quote:

I haven't tried acacia, but I've tried several other fiber supplements. I started at an incredibly low dose and every time ended up with D, gas, and agonizing cramps (the kind where you wish you were dead). Generally it was within a day or so. My diet is very high-SF. In fact, that is probably 90% of my diet. (I know, I know, not healthy.)




See, this is so interesting. A half-cup of applesauce contains 1 gram of SF; 1/2 cup of oatmeal contains 2 grams of soluble fiber. One-quarter teaspoon of acacia - which seems to have more SF per teaspoon than any other SFS - has .625 grams of SF. Presumably, if you took different SFS they contained different kinds of fiber so how could it be an allergy? And if you started at a low dose, you were getting far less than 1 gram of SF. Why would a body tolerate a high-SF diet, but rebel when confronted with less than 1 gram of SF from an SFS? I really want to be around when "they" finally figure out IBS and can answer that one.




This doesn't make sense to me, either. It makes me mad because I still haven't stabilized and SFSes are supposed to help so much! I keep going back to the SFS shelves at the store to see if there is anything new or that I have missed. The pharmacy people probably know me by sight and feel sorry for the girl who must have hideous C to be always hanging around the laxatives!

I do have a definite bad reaction to gums, which I didn't figure out until I realized I always had an attack if I ate even a small amount of gummi candy. But, that only explains the SFSes that are guar gum or arabic gum (are there any other kinds?). Maybe it's just the "etc." stuff in the other fibers? I think Heather says Acacia and Benefiber are the only 100% fibers out there.


--------------------
jen

"It's one of the most serious things that can possibly happen to one in a battle -- to get one's head cut off." -- LC

Print     Remind Me     Notify Moderator    

Entire thread
* Has anyone else w/ IBS-C had increased bloating, gas and pain w/ acacia?
lithelady
06/21/05 02:04 PM
* I'll never understand...
Cyndy
06/22/05 07:32 PM
* Here's something I'm curious about
Sand
06/25/05 09:25 AM
* Re: Here's something I'm curious about
jen1013
06/26/05 07:59 AM
* Re: Here's something I'm curious about
Sand
06/26/05 03:54 PM
* Sand, this is confusing to me
Cyndy
06/28/05 07:49 AM
* Re: Here's something I'm curious about
jen1013
06/27/05 04:59 PM
* Jen1013 - what's in the different SFS
Sand
06/30/05 08:18 AM
* Re: Jen1013 - what's in the different SFS
jen1013
06/30/05 06:08 PM
* Jen1013 - Fingers crossed. Toes, too. -nt-
Sand
07/01/05 08:30 AM
* Thanks for all the input everyone
lithelady
06/27/05 09:43 PM
* If you're goin to stick with the Benefiber...
Linz
06/28/05 04:21 AM
* Re: Here's something I'm curious about
lj
06/25/05 03:37 PM
* LJ - When you say "the lowest dose"...
Sand
06/26/05 03:58 PM
* Re: LJ - When you say "the lowest dose"...
lj
06/26/05 10:09 PM
* Re: LJ - When you say "the lowest dose"...
Sand
06/27/05 04:28 AM
* It is possible to be allergic o it!
Linz
06/26/05 01:51 AM
* Sounds like you were allergic to it!
Linz
06/27/05 02:30 AM
* Re: Here's something I'm curious about
Yoda (formerly Hans)
06/25/05 03:45 PM
* Re: I'll never understand...
retrograde
06/22/05 09:46 PM
* I guess I just looked at Acaca as...
Cyndy
06/23/05 04:59 AM
* This is right...
HeatherAdministrator
06/24/05 12:58 AM
* I don't understand the problem
Linz
06/23/05 05:04 AM
* Well, I am confused because I thought Heather...
Cyndy
06/23/05 09:56 AM
* Re: Well, I am confused because I thought Heather...
Linz
06/23/05 01:28 PM
* Can I just also point out here...
Linz
06/22/05 10:29 PM
* Re: Can I just also point out here...
Sand
06/25/05 09:20 AM
* Some people can't cope with a high dose...
Linz
06/25/05 09:44 AM
* Re: Some people can't cope with a high dose...
Sand
06/25/05 11:10 AM
* If it ain't broke, don't fix it! -nt
Linz
06/25/05 02:30 PM
* Re: Has anyone else w/ IBS-C had increased bloating, gas and pain w/ acacia?
AstroChick
06/22/05 09:33 AM
* Re: Has anyone else w/ IBS-C had increased bloating, gas and pain w/ acacia?
bamagirl
06/22/05 09:00 AM
* Re: Has anyone else w/ IBS-C had increased bloating, gas and pain w/ acacia?
Linz
06/22/05 06:17 AM
* Re: Has anyone else w/ IBS-C had increased bloating, gas and pain w/ acacia?
e_mcmaster
06/22/05 08:18 AM

Extra information
0 registered and 1007 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Heather 



Permissions
      You cannot post until you login
      You cannot reply until you login
      HTML is enabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 8625

Jump to

| Privacy statement Help for IBS Home

*
UBB.threads™ 6.2


HelpForIBS.com BBB Business Review