All Boards >> Eating for IBS Diet Board

View all threads Posts     Flat     Threaded

Re: Probiotics----even if you tested negative for SIBO?
      01/04/08 04:50 AM
Syl

Reged: 03/13/05
Posts: 5499
Loc: SK, CANADA

While a few studies and web-based news reports/articles make strong claims for the role of SIBO in IBS most recent research articles dispute the claim and the validity of the lactulose breath test as well. For example, the recently published articles listed below conclude:
Quote:

1. The data do not support an important role for SIBO according to commonly used clinical definitions, in IBS. However, mildly increased counts of small-bowel bacteria seem to be more common in IBS, and needs further investigation. Motility alterations could not reliably predict altered small-bowel bacterial flora.

2. Some propose that bacterial overgrowth is a common causative factor in the pathogenesis of symptoms in IBS; others point to evidence suggesting that the cause stems from more subtle qualitative changes in the colonic flora. Neither hypothesis has been confirmed, but the likelihood now seems remote that bacterial overgrowth will prove to be a major factor in what will eventually be defined as IBS.

3. In summary, we failed to detect a significant association between SIBO and IBS using either the LHBT (lactulost breath test) or the more specific 14C-D-xylose breath test. Our results suggest that studies employing the LHBT to diagnosis SIBO require further validation of the applied criteria. Additional studies are needed to clarify whether patients in different geographical locations have significant differing bacterial flora and whether these differences might be important in the expression of human illness.




If you want a list of research references from reputable journals that you can read I would be happy to provide them to you. Also, check back through the posting on this web site and see how many people have been tested for SIBO and either tested negative or had no/negative results with SIBO treatment. Anyway - eventually, the research will make things clearer

Good luck with your SIBO tests. Tells us how it goes.

Reference
Posserud, I., P. O. Stotzer, E. S. Bjornsson, H. Abrahamsson, and M. Simren, 2007: Small intestinal bacterial overgrowth in patients with irritable bowel syndrome. Gut, 56, 802-808

Quigley, E. M. M., 2007: Bacteria: A New Player in Gastrointestinal Motility Disorders--Infections, Bacterial Overgrowth, and Probiotics. Gastroenterology Clinics of North America Gastrointestinal Motility Disorders, 36, 735-748.

Walters, B. and S. J. Vanner, 2005: Detection of Bacterial Overgrowth in IBS Using the Lactulose H2 Breath Test: Comparison with 14C-d-Xylose and Healthy Controls. The American Journal of Gastroenterology, 100, 1566-1570.

--------------------
STABLE: ♂, IBS-D 50+ years - Science of IBS

The FODMAP Approach to Managing IBS Symptoms
Evidence-based Dietary Management of Functional GI Symptoms: The FODMAP Approach
FODMAP Chart & Cheatsheet
The Role of Food & Dietary Intervention in IBS

Print     Remind Me     Notify Moderator    

Entire thread
* IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
gigi1234
12/29/07 06:29 AM
* Re: IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
Jordy
01/01/08 08:32 AM
* Re: IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
auntdebs318
01/01/08 08:16 AM
* Re: IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
gigi1234
01/01/08 09:48 AM
* for Gigi
Zara
12/30/07 02:25 PM
* Re: for Gigi
gigi1234
12/31/07 08:50 PM
* Re: IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
CJIBSDG
12/30/07 02:15 PM
* Re: IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
gigi1234
12/31/07 08:54 PM
* Re: IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
CJIBSDG
12/29/07 08:19 AM
* Re: IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
gigi1234
12/29/07 02:01 PM
* Re: IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
CJIBSDG
12/29/07 06:55 PM
* SIBO and IBS
Syl
12/30/07 06:44 AM
* Re: SIBO and IBS
CJIBSDG
12/30/07 01:59 PM
* Re: SIBO and IBS

12/31/07 08:19 PM
* Re: SIBO and IBS
CJIBSDG
01/01/08 11:22 AM
* To: CJ Re: SIBO and IBS

01/01/08 07:55 PM
* Re: To: CJ Re: SIBO and IBS
Jordy
01/02/08 08:09 AM
* To Jordy Re: To: CJ Re: SIBO and IBS

01/02/08 08:57 AM
* Re: To Jordy Re: To: CJ Re: SIBO and IBS
Jordy
01/02/08 09:51 AM
* Re: To Jordy Re: To: CJ Re: SIBO and IBS

01/02/08 10:48 AM
* Question for Gigi
CJIBSDG
01/01/08 04:00 PM
* Re: Question for Gigi
gigi1234
01/02/08 09:05 AM
* Re: SIBO and IBS
Jordy
01/01/08 08:30 AM
* Re: SIBO and IBS

01/01/08 08:03 PM
* Re: SIBO and IBS
Jordy
01/02/08 08:16 AM
* To Jordy Re: SIBO and IBS

01/02/08 08:48 AM
* Re: To Jordy Re: SIBO and IBS
Jordy
01/02/08 09:55 AM
* Re: To Jordy Re: SIBO and IBS

01/02/08 10:53 AM
* Re: To Jordy Re: SIBO and IBS
CJIBSDG
01/02/08 04:22 PM
* About the bananas
Jordy
01/04/08 08:46 AM
* Re: About the bananas
auntdebs318
01/04/08 09:13 AM
* Re: About the bananas
CJIBSDG
01/04/08 01:37 PM
* Re: To Jordy Re: SIBO and IBS

01/03/08 07:59 AM
* Re: To Sarah Re: SIBO and IBS
CJIBSDG
01/03/08 04:50 PM
* Re: To Sarah Re: SIBO and IBS
Jordy
01/04/08 08:33 AM
* Re: To Sarah Re: SIBO and IBS
CJIBSDG
01/03/08 05:00 PM
* Re: SIBO and IBS
gigi1234
01/01/08 09:43 AM
* Probiotics
Syl
01/01/08 04:33 AM
* Re: Probiotics----even if you tested negative for SIBO?
Jordy
01/02/08 08:18 AM
* Re: Probiotics----even if you tested negative for SIBO?
Syl
01/02/08 08:27 AM
* Re: Probiotics----even if you tested negative for SIBO?
CJIBSDG
01/02/08 04:00 PM
* Re: Probiotics----even if you tested negative for SIBO?
Syl
01/02/08 04:55 PM
* Re: Probiotics----even if you tested negative for SIBO?
CJIBSDG
01/03/08 05:19 PM
* Re: Probiotics----even if you tested negative for SIBO?
Syl
01/04/08 04:50 AM
* For Syl - Probiotics----even if you tested negative for SIBO?
CJIBSDG
01/04/08 01:57 PM
* Thank you!-nt
Jordy
01/02/08 08:28 AM
* Re: Probiotics
gigi1234
01/01/08 09:52 AM
* Re: Probiotics
Jordy
01/01/08 08:28 AM
* Re: SIBO and IBS
Syl
12/30/07 05:42 PM
* Re: SIBO and IBS
Zara
12/30/07 07:31 PM
* Re: SIBO and IBS
CJIBSDG
12/31/07 04:17 PM
* Re: IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
gigi1234
12/29/07 10:05 PM
* Re: IBS-C Gas Bloating Probiotics Success Story
CJIBSDG
12/30/07 05:45 AM

Extra information
0 registered and 226 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Heather 



Permissions
      You cannot post until you login
      You cannot reply until you login
      HTML is enabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 62681

Jump to

| Privacy statement Help for IBS Home

*
UBB.threads™ 6.2


HelpForIBS.com BBB Business Review