Irritable Bowel Syndrome Message Boards | Re: milk (message for Jeio)

Search | Login
Who's Online | Help

All Boards >> Eating for IBS Diet Board

Posts Flat Threaded

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
03/01/07 12:35 PM

Sand

Reged: 12/13/04
Posts: 4490
Loc: West Orange, NJ (IBS-D)

Quote:

History is littered with anecdotal evidence that has been disproved by scientific research (which is experimental).

I guess as usually we shall continue to disagree

History is also littered with scientific research that has proven to be incomplete or incorrect with further research. The most horrific example of this is probably thalidomide. In the medical field, ulcers leap to mind. In the health/food field, one thinks of margarine being touted as safer than butter - for decades.

If there was a medical/scientific cure for IBS or a medical/scientific fix for IBS symptoms, that would be one thing. In that case, if Heather was giving advice based on anecdotes and experience that was contrary to the medical/scientific advice, I'd be screaming my head off. (Well, actually, I'd be avoiding this site like the plague.) However, since the medical/scientific approach is a broken reed when it comes to IBS, all IBSers can do is rely on anecdotal/experiential evidence to try to control our symtoms as best we can.

Heather's assertion that her experience and that of other IBSers indicates diary is problematic apart from the lactose is a pretty benign statement and cutting out dairy is a pretty benign action.

I don't know what point you're trying to make by explaing that scientific research is experimental.

--------------------
[Research tells us fourteen out of any ten individuals likes chocolate. - Sandra Boynton]

Print Remind Me Notify Moderator

Entire thread

milk
line415
02/27/07 07:37 PM

not getting involved
Little Minnie
03/02/07 12:29 PM

Stop!!!
oldestofseven
03/02/07 08:33 AM

Re: milk
atomic rose
03/02/07 08:08 AM

Re: milk
keepsmiling
03/02/07 08:34 AM

Re: milk
GaiasSong
03/02/07 09:09 AM

Re: milk
dmdentre
03/01/07 06:19 PM

Re: milk
Jennifer86
03/02/07 08:24 AM

Re: milk
oldestofseven
03/02/07 08:36 AM

Read this
Syl
02/28/07 06:37 AM

Thank you!
Jeio
03/01/07 03:53 AM

Re: milk
oldestofseven
02/28/07 05:37 AM

2% vs FF milk
Jeio
02/28/07 06:25 AM

Re: 2% vs FF milk
oldestofseven
02/28/07 07:38 AM

No, not lactose free, but lactaid should take care of it -nt-
Jeio
03/01/07 03:54 AM

Re: milk
Jeio
02/28/07 04:08 AM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Jennifer86
02/28/07 11:01 AM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Jeio
03/01/07 04:04 AM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Jennifer86
03/01/07 12:45 PM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Sand
03/01/07 08:50 AM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Syl
03/01/07 10:18 AM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Sand
03/01/07 11:09 AM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Syl
03/01/07 11:32 AM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Sand
03/01/07 12:35 PM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Syl
03/01/07 02:57 PM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Sand
03/01/07 03:22 PM

Re: milk BRAT is Bananas, Rice, Applesauce & Toast not milk...
LtDanFan
03/01/07 08:57 AM

Re: milk BRAT is Bananas, Rice, Applesauce & Toast not milk...Oops! (m)
Sand
03/01/07 09:01 AM

Re: milk BRAT is Bananas, Rice, Applesauce & Toast not milk...Oops! (m)
LtDanFan
03/01/07 11:30 AM

Re: milk BRAT is Bananas, Rice, Applesauce & Toast not milk...Oops! (m)
Sand
03/01/07 12:07 PM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
line415
03/01/07 07:52 AM

Re: milk (message for Jeio)
Jeio
03/01/07 02:45 PM

Jeio
Sand
03/01/07 03:30 PM

Rice milk does NOT cause C!
Lisa Marie
02/28/07 12:47 PM

Re: Rice milk does NOT cause C!
Jennifer86
02/28/07 01:45 PM

Re: Rice milk does NOT cause C!
Gracie
02/28/07 05:05 PM

This is ridiculous!
Flipada
02/28/07 06:00 PM

Re: Good post, Flipada. I agree with you! -nt-
lalala
03/01/07 11:17 AM

I'm with Flipada, too. -nt-
Sand
03/01/07 08:42 AM

Re: This is ridiculous!
Jeio
03/01/07 04:27 AM

Re: This is ridiculous!
Gracie
03/01/07 02:24 PM

Re: This is ridiculous!
Jeio
03/01/07 03:05 PM

Re: This is ridiculous!
Gracie
03/01/07 04:23 PM

I think you're missing the point...
Lisa Marie
03/01/07 03:59 PM

whaaaat??
jen1013
03/01/07 01:58 PM

Re: whaaaat??
Jeio
03/01/07 03:11 PM

Jeio please stay...and everyone else, let's drop it! Sorry!! n/t
line415
03/01/07 05:31 PM

Re: This is ridiculous!
Jennifer86
03/01/07 03:14 AM

Re: This is ridiculous!
Jeio
03/01/07 04:28 AM

Re: This is ridiculous!
Gracie
02/28/07 07:56 PM

I'm with Flipada on this one.
hohoyumyum
02/28/07 07:29 PM

Re: Rice milk does NOT cause C!
Lisa Marie
02/28/07 04:16 PM

Re: Rice milk does NOT cause C!
LtDanFan
02/28/07 02:26 PM

How long have you been trying?
DianeM
02/28/07 04:29 PM

Re: How long have you been trying?Diane M
LtDanFan
02/28/07 05:58 PM

Re: Rice milk does NOT cause C!
moon01064
02/28/07 01:39 PM

Re: Rice milk does NOT cause C!
line415
02/28/07 04:19 PM

Re: Rice milk does NOT cause C!
Lisa Marie
02/28/07 04:21 PM

Raisins cause gas???
line415
02/28/07 04:23 PM

Re: Raisins cause gas???
Lisa Marie
02/28/07 04:28 PM

Re: Raisins cause gas???
line415
02/28/07 04:32 PM

Re: Raisins cause gas???
Lisa Marie
02/28/07 04:51 PM

Re: Rice milk does NOT cause C!
Lisa Marie
02/28/07 04:13 PM

Re: Rice milk does NOT cause C!Lisa
LtDanFan
02/28/07 06:01 PM

Re: Rice milk does NOT cause C!Lisa
Lisa Marie
03/01/07 10:23 AM

I was afraid of this...
line415
03/01/07 08:03 AM

Re: milk
Gracie
02/27/07 07:41 PM

Re: milk
LtDanFan
02/28/07 06:23 AM

Re: milk
Jeio
02/28/07 06:34 AM

Re: milk/ FF real milk more lactose
LtDanFan
02/28/07 07:22 AM

Thank you for all your responses...
line415
02/28/07 10:22 AM

Re: Thank you for all your responses...
moon01064
02/28/07 12:58 PM

Extra information

0 registered and 1008 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator: Heather

Permissions
      You cannot post until you login
      You cannot reply until you login
      HTML is enabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 51271

| Privacy statement

Help for IBS Home

UBB.threads™ 6.2