It's supposed to be first 4. Heather had them in the newsletter before, and it says 4 there: web page Heather made a few adjustments to make it easier to understand. I just realized she left it at 14 muffins in the newsletter though! LOL That's too funny, because you can see in this thread Sharon said she'd made that mistake and where do you see muffin tins with 14 holes. Sharon is so funny - I really miss her on the boards.