All Boards >> Eating for IBS Diet Board

View all threads Posts     Flat     Threaded

Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
      06/17/07 11:01 PM
Naturapanic

Reged: 02/16/06
Posts: 856


Does anybody else find that prebiotics and perhaps probiotics are a waste of money?

When I almost two years ago started taking Benefiber powder, I never felt better than I did the first couple of days.
My stomach was emptying at a record pace, clearing up my c.

However within a few weeks, while my stomach didn't regress, the relief started to diminsh.
I didn't feel that great anymore and it seemed to have been a big boost only short term.

Since then I have added prescription Miralax and Acidphillus Probiotic.

I also tried Heather's Acadia.
I don't really feel anything substantial.
It feels as if, taking a prebiotic at first helps a ton, but then the body gets used to it, adjusts, and it's losses it's effectiveness.
It's like if I stop now my C might get worse, but if I continue it's not likely to improve.
The prebiotic seems to only help noticably at first after which it appears to just keep things from getting much worse, which even now isn't suceeding.

I wanted to know if others have had this experience and if you can suggest anything.
I have thought about switching, but to what?
I tried Citrucell and Acadia, both of which were no different, less if anything effective than Benefiber.

I could increase the does, I take two utensial NOT tablespoon spoons per day.
However that could be counterproductive or if helpful, last short term.

I'm getting frustrated spending time, effort, and my money on products which give mixed at best results.
I don't want to quit in a fit of rage and hurt myself yet I don't want to needlsy invest.
Thanks.

--------------------
IBS-C and Bloating

Print     Remind Me     Notify Moderator    

Entire thread
* Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
Naturapanic
06/17/07 11:01 PM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
ECM
06/19/07 08:27 PM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
Naturapanic
06/19/07 10:04 PM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
santino75
06/20/07 12:19 PM
* I'd second this, and would urge her to try hypnotherapy to break this cycle. -nt-
HeatherAdministrator
06/20/07 03:30 PM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
ECM
06/20/07 07:06 AM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
bbgem1
06/20/07 09:32 AM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
Gracie
06/18/07 07:59 PM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
bbgem1
06/20/07 09:28 AM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
Gracie
06/20/07 04:38 PM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
Naturapanic
06/18/07 11:42 PM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
Gracie
06/19/07 04:13 PM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
Naturapanic
06/19/07 10:03 PM
* Prebiotics -- Probiotics - IBS - C --
avjens
07/17/07 07:48 AM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
ElenaDragon
06/20/07 07:07 AM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
Naturapanic
06/20/07 11:44 AM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
ECM
06/20/07 04:09 PM
* Just for clarity, it's Acacia with a "c" - there is no such thing as Acadia. - nt-
HeatherAdministrator
06/20/07 03:29 PM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
bbgem1
06/18/07 07:18 AM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
Naturapanic
06/18/07 08:30 AM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
bbgem1
06/18/07 08:47 AM
* Re: Prebiotics...A Waste of Money?
Naturapanic
06/18/07 11:42 AM

Extra information
0 registered and 691 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Heather 



Permissions
      You cannot post until you login
      You cannot reply until you login
      HTML is enabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 4494

Jump to

| Privacy statement Help for IBS Home

*
UBB.threads™ 6.2


HelpForIBS.com BBB Business Review