All Boards >> Eating for IBS Diet Board

View all threads Posts     Flat     Threaded

Re: Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
      08/23/05 02:09 PM
badlydrawnboy

Reged: 03/01/05
Posts: 111


Hi Sand!

The results of my sitz marker test were (to me at least) inconclusive. I was really constipated when I started the test and at some point during it the aloe vera I was taking kicked in and I got diarrhea. So the markers were gone by the time I went back five days later.

Anyhow, even if the markers were still present, what would the test have told me? That I'm constipated! You don't say! Yes, I understand that it can tell me the difference between slow transit constipation and some kind of obstruction. But I'm mostly interested in results. Even my primary care doc said a lot of allopathic (Western) diagnostic tests are "mental masturbation" (his words, not mine!) because it's just a bunch of high-tech neato gadgetry that doesn't produce information that can lead to a successful treatment.

In other words, the doctors mostly still don't have a clue about IBS. But then we knew that already.

I'm reading a book (and following the program) called "Restoring Your Digestive Health" by Dr. Joseph Brasco and Jordan Rubin. It's a completely different approach than what is followed here. I've been seeing some positive results for the first time in a long, long while. Anyhow, Dr. Brasco says in his chapter on IBS that it is "very likely a group of many disorders that have been clumped under one name because we don't understand the individual disorders enough". I know Heather has said something similar, and that to me explains why people respond so wildly differently to a given approach (like the IBS diet, for example).

In the case of what you mentioned, I suspect that constipation can be caused by both an overly relaxed and overly stimulated colon. And unfortunately (for me, and other IBS-C folks) it can be both. I know that when I have a lot of cramps and spasms, I won't be having a BM the next day. Likewise, there is a familiar "nothing happening" or "dead" sensation when it seems like everything is just completely stopped that also tells me I'm going to be backed up. What's bizarre is that for some people, the exact opposite is true: spasms mean an immediate trip to the bathroom.

It's a mystery. Just stinks that we're the subjects of it.

Chris

Print     Remind Me     Notify Moderator    

Entire thread
* Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
badlydrawnboy
08/21/05 10:01 AM
* Re: Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
sgcray
12/01/14 09:49 PM
* Re: Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
Ballinsw
08/25/05 11:55 PM
* Nope, it should help if it's IBS constipation
HeatherAdministrator
08/23/05 06:38 PM
* Thanks Heather
AmandaPanda, J.D.
08/24/05 07:41 PM
* Thanks Heather!
bamagirl
08/24/05 05:35 AM
* Wondering the same -- Heather?
AmandaPanda, J.D.
08/23/05 04:39 PM
* I want to know the same thing!
bamagirl
08/23/05 01:22 PM
* Re: Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
Sand
08/23/05 12:31 PM
* Re: Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
badlydrawnboy
08/23/05 02:09 PM
* Cochrane's Aphorism
Sand
08/24/05 04:44 PM
* Re: Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
Johnny T. Reb
08/24/05 05:58 AM
* Re: Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
badlydrawnboy
08/24/05 09:37 AM
* Re: Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
Johnny T. Reb
08/24/05 10:54 AM
* Re: Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
badlydrawnboy
08/24/05 01:56 PM
* Re: Can too much peppermint cause constipation?
lalala
08/24/05 02:27 PM
* What are some examples of fermented foods?
Cyndy
08/24/05 02:33 PM
* Re: What are some examples of fermented foods?
lalala
08/24/05 02:53 PM
* Thanks Maria
Cyndy
08/25/05 09:30 AM
* Re: Cyndy
lalala
08/25/05 09:59 AM
* Maria
Sand
08/26/05 10:18 AM
* Cyndy
lalala
08/24/05 02:57 PM
* Re: What are some examples of fermented foods?
badlydrawnboy
08/24/05 02:39 PM
* Re: What are some examples of fermented foods?
Cyndy
08/24/05 02:45 PM
* Re: More fermented foods
Wind
08/25/05 05:16 PM
* These are definitely not all safe for IBS...
HeatherAdministrator
08/25/05 06:31 PM
* Re: These are definitely not all safe for IBS...
Wind
08/25/05 07:32 PM
* Re: What are some examples of fermented foods?
badlydrawnboy
08/24/05 04:48 PM
* Thanks for the info
Cyndy
08/25/05 09:00 AM
* Re: Thanks for the info
badlydrawnboy
08/25/05 09:22 AM
* Re: What are some examples of fermented foods?
Johnny T. Reb
08/25/05 07:57 AM
* Re: What are some examples of fermented foods?
badlydrawnboy
08/25/05 09:19 AM
* Thank you, Chris. I appreciate that you are concerned about this..
HeatherAdministrator
08/25/05 10:01 AM
* Bob, just remember..
Cyndy
08/25/05 08:33 AM
* Re: Bob, just remember...Yeah, better safe than sorry
Johnny T. Reb
08/25/05 10:07 AM
* Kefir starters
Kandee
08/25/05 10:58 PM
* Re: Kefir starters - Thanks, Kandee. Safe Ranch Dressing w/out soy - yum. -nt-
Sand
08/26/05 09:51 AM
* Re: Kefir starters, Thanks very much Kandee -Bob -nt-
Johnny T. Reb
08/26/05 05:30 AM
* You're welcome Sand and Bob..hope that helped -nt-
Kandee
08/26/05 05:07 PM
* Chris
Cyndy
08/24/05 09:57 AM

Extra information
0 registered and 1740 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Heather 



Permissions
      You cannot post until you login
      You cannot reply until you login
      HTML is enabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 42826

Jump to

| Privacy statement Help for IBS Home

*
UBB.threads™ 6.2


HelpForIBS.com BBB Business Review